Importing from China: The Truth About LCL Scam Fees (and How to Protect Yourself)

Prepaying your freight from China should mean peace of mind — but for many importers, it leads to unexpected invoices, mystery charges, and mounting costs. If you’ve ever wondered why “all-in” LCL shipping costs aren’t really all-in, you’re not alone.

In this guide, you’ll learn exactly where hidden fees come from, which ones are legitimate, which ones aren’t, and how to protect your business from costly surprises when importing Less than Container Load (LCL) shipments from China.

1. What is LCL Shipping and Why Does It Attract Extra Fees?

LCL stands for Less than Container Load, meaning your cargo shares container space with other shipments. It’s ideal for small shipments, but comes with extra steps — and extra costs — because your goods must be consolidated at origin and deconsolidated at destination.

Every extra touchpoint — loading, unloading, sorting, storing, paperwork — creates opportunities for fees. Unlike Full Container Load (FCL), where one party owns the whole box, LCL shipping splits responsibility, which often splits and multiplies fees too.

Key friction points in LCL that generate extra charges:

Consolidation at the port of origin
Deconsolidation at the destination port
Multiple handling steps (loading, unloading, warehouse storage)
Additional customs and security checks
Document processing for multiple shippers

2. The Most Common Hidden LCL Fees (and What They Actually Mean)

Many importers are shocked when a shipment that was “freight prepaid” suddenly comes with a second invoice on arrival. These unexpected costs often fall into one of the following categories:

Fee Name	Description
Terminal Handling Charge (THC)	Charged by the port for moving containers; applies at both origin and destination.
China Import Service Fee (CISF)	Charged by destination agents under CIF/CFR terms; covers their operational cut for handling LCL cargo from China.
Bunker Adjustment Factor (BAF)	Fuel surcharge that varies with oil prices, often unclear or outdated.
Documentation Fee	Cost for processing delivery orders, customs entries, or issuing certificates.
Port Congestion Fee	Imposed when destination ports are backed up, even if not always justified.
Security Fee / TSF	Charged for port and cargo security screening; typically flat-rate per shipment.
Storage / Demurrage	Applies when cargo is left too long at port or CFS; can escalate rapidly after a few free days.

🚩 Red Flag: These fees aren’t inherently scams — but if you didn’t agree to them or they weren’t disclosed upfront, it’s a sign your freight forwarder or seller may be hiding true costs.

3. Why “Prepaid Freight” Doesn’t Mean All-Inclusive Shipping

One of the biggest misconceptions in LCL shipping is that if freight is “prepaid,” there should be no more charges. Unfortunately, this is rarely true — especially under CIF or CFR Incoterms.

“Freight Prepaid” means the ocean freight from origin port to destination port is covered — not the destination charges.
Destination fees (THC, D/O, CISF, port fees, and local delivery) are usually excluded and become the responsibility of the importer.
If you did not agree to a DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) arrangement, expect additional fees at destination — especially with LCL shipments.

Tip: Ask for a fully itemized breakdown before booking. If a forwarder or seller refuses to share destination costs upfront, that’s a red flag.

4. How Incoterms Like FOB vs. CIF Can Determine What You Pay

Incoterm	Who Controls Freight?	Who Pays Destination Charges?
FOB (Free On Board)	You (the buyer)	You choose your own forwarder; fees are more transparent.
CIF / CFR (Cost, Insurance & Freight)	Seller (but only to port)	You pay whatever the seller’s agent charges — often inflated.
DDP (Delivered Duty Paid)	Seller	No extra charges (in theory), but rarely used for LCL unless negotiated.

Pro tip: Always request FOB terms from your supplier when importing LCL cargo. It gives you control over the forwarder and prevents hidden destination fees.

5. Red Flags: When LCL Fees Cross the Line

Some LCL charges are legitimate, but many importers report “fee inflation” — especially under CIF/CFR terms. Watch out for these red flags:

Unitemized Invoices: If you’re just sent a total amount without a fee breakdown, that’s a problem.
Oddly Named Charges: Terms like “China Import Service Fee,” “Groupage Fee,” or “Document Recovery” often disguise padded costs.
Bunker Adjustment Factor (BAF) Hype: While BAF is a real surcharge for fuel, if oil prices are low and BAF is still rising, ask questions.
Pressure to Use Seller’s Agent: If you’re told you “must” use the forwarder chosen by the exporter, you’re likely being funneled into a markup trap.

Remember: Even if you feel stuck once the cargo is in transit, document everything. You may be able to push back on excessive charges before final delivery.

6. Best Practices: How to Avoid “Scam Fees” in LCL Shipping

Use these strategies to reduce surprise charges and build better control over your imports:

Always ask for an itemized quote: Include origin + destination charges, documentation, deconsolidation, and local delivery.
Use FOB terms whenever possible: This lets you pick your own forwarder and avoid inflated local fees.
Vet your forwarder: Look for reviews, licensing, and responsiveness. Avoid freight quotes that sound “too good to be true.”
Confirm destination port storage rules: Learn how many free days you get before demurrage starts adding up.
Avoid peak season surprises: Plan early to sidestep seasonal surcharges and port congestion.

Bonus tip: Consider consolidating multiple small orders into fewer LCL shipments or switching to FCL if volume allows — the per-unit cost is often lower and simpler.

7. Quick Reference: What’s a “Normal” LCL Fee?

LCL destination charges vary, but you can benchmark against common industry ranges:

Fee Type	Reasonable Range (Per CBM)	Red Flag
THC (Terminal Handling)	$20–$50	Over $100 with no explanation
Documentation Fee	$25–$75 flat	Above $100 or vague description
China Import Service Fee	$30–$80 per CBM	Flat fees above $300 for < 5 CBM
BAF (Fuel Surcharge)	$10–$30 per CBM	Not adjusted with fuel price changes

For a typical 4 CBM shipment, total destination fees of $400–$700 may be normal — anything well above that should raise questions.

8. Final Advice: Transparency Is Your Best Defense

If you’re consistently seeing “surprise fees,” it’s time to rethink how you book freight:

Don’t buy freight through your supplier — they’re often incentivized to partner with agents who add hidden charges.
Switch to FOB and choose a trusted forwarder with transparent pricing and good communication.
Ask for fee benchmarks in advance — and cross-reference quotes with industry norms.
Document your shipping terms in writing — especially Incoterms, included fees, and handoff responsibilities.

Summary: There’s no silver bullet, but understanding the structure of LCL charges — and recognizing when they go off the rails — can protect your margins and give you back control of your logistics costs.

Why overpay for visibility? TRADLINX saves you 40% with transparent per–Master B/L pricing. Get 99% accuracy, 12 updates daily, and 80% ETA accuracy improvements, trusted by 83,000+ logistics teams and global leaders like Samsung and LG Chem.